Abortion Legislation Bill — In Committee — Part 1 — Conscientious objection
Summary
This Supplementary Order Paper amends clause 7 of the Abortion Legislation Bill by amending new section 19 and replacing new section 20, relating to conscientious objection and provisions related to employment relations. The wording for this amendment has been taken from section 8 of the End of Life Choice Act 2019, which addresses a comparable matter of conscientious objection.
The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 469 in the name of Chris Penk to new section 20 in clause 7 be agreed to.
Mover of amendment
Votes Not passed by a large majority
Amendment not agreed to.
36 Voted For
82 Voted Against
2 Absent
- Michael Wood Labour Party
- Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi National Party
- Maggie Barry National Party
- Andrew Bayly National Party
- David Bennett National Party
- Dan Bidois National Party
- Simon Bridges National Party
- Simeon Brown National Party
- Gerry Brownlee National Party
- Jacqui Dean National Party
- Sarah Dowie National Party
- Paulo Garcia National Party
- Paul Goldsmith National Party
- Nathan Guy National Party
- Joanne Hayes National Party
- Harete Hipango National Party
- Brett Hudson National Party
- Denise Lee National Party
- Melissa Lee National Party
- Agnes Loheni National Party
- Tim Macindoe National Party
- Todd McClay National Party
- Mark Mitchell National Party
- Todd Muller National Party
- Alfred Ngaro National Party
- Simon O'Connor National Party
- Parmjeet Parmar National Party
- Chris Penk National Party
- Maureen Pugh National Party
- Alastair Scott National Party
- Nick Smith National Party
- Anne Tolley National Party
- Louise Upston National Party
- Hamish Walker National Party
- Jonathan Young National Party
- Lawrence Yule National Party
- David Seymour ACT Party
- Marama Davidson Green Party
- Julie Anne Genter Green Party
- Golriz Ghahraman Green Party
- Gareth Hughes Green Party
- Jan Logie Green Party
- Eugenie Sage Green Party
- James Shaw Green Party
- Chlöe Swarbrick Green Party
- Jami-Lee Ross Independent
- Kiritapu Allan Labour Party
- Ginny Andersen Labour Party
- Jacinda Ardern Labour Party
- David Clark Labour Party
- Tamati Coffey Labour Party
- Liz Craig Labour Party
- Clare Curran Labour Party
- Kelvin Davis Labour Party
- Ruth Dyson Labour Party
- Paul Eagle Labour Party
- Kris Faafoi Labour Party
- Peeni Henare Labour Party
- Chris Hipkins Labour Party
- Raymond Huo Labour Party
- Willie Jackson Labour Party
- Anahila Kanongata'a-Suisuiki Labour Party
- Iain Lees-Galloway Labour Party
- Andrew Little Labour Party
- Marja Lubeck Labour Party
- Jo Luxton Labour Party
- Nanaia Mahuta Labour Party
- Trevor Mallard Labour Party
- Kieran McAnulty Labour Party
- Stuart Nash Labour Party
- Damien O'Connor Labour Party
- Greg O'Connor Labour Party
- David Parker Labour Party
- Willow-Jean Prime Labour Party
- Priyanca Radhakrishnan Labour Party
- Grant Robertson Labour Party
- Adrian Rurawhe Labour Party
- Deborah Russell Labour Party
- Jenny Salesa Labour Party
- Carmel Sepuloni Labour Party
- Aupito William Sio Labour Party
- Jamie Strange Labour Party
- Jan Tinetti Labour Party
- Rino Tirikatene Labour Party
- Phil Twyford Labour Party
- Louisa Wall Labour Party
- Angie Warren-Clark Labour Party
- Duncan Webb Labour Party
- Meka Whaitiri Labour Party
- Poto Williams Labour Party
- Megan Woods Labour Party
- Amy Adams National Party
- Paula Bennett National Party
- David Carter National Party
- Matt Doocey National Party
- Andrew Falloon National Party
- Nikki Kaye National Party
- Matt King National Party
- Barbara Kuriger National Party
- Ian McKelvie National Party
- Shane Reti National Party
- Scott Simpson National Party
- Stuart Smith National Party
- Erica Stanford National Party
- Nicky Wagner National Party
- Nicola Willis National Party
- Michael Woodhouse National Party
- Jian Yang National Party
- Tim van de Molen National Party
- Darroch Ball NZ First
- Shane Jones NZ First
- Jenny Marcroft NZ First
- Ron Mark NZ First
- Tracey Martin NZ First
- Clayton Mitchell NZ First
- Mark Patterson NZ First
- Winston Peters NZ First
- Fletcher Tabuteau NZ First
- Chris Bishop National Party
- Judith Collins National Party